Sunday, October 11, 2009

"Today's weapon of choice"

That's how Colt describes its product, the M4, which is standard issue in the US military and has impressive furniture options. It's a stubbier version of the former standby, the M16, firing a 5.56 mm round and can be retrofitted with an M203 grenade launcher (With other grenade launchers, in the SEALs we would do the same with our NATO 7.62 mm M14s. They were called thumpers, although I never needed the use for one).

Until recently, the M4 has enjoyed a well-deserved reputation as a reliable weapon. Yet the disaster in the, until recently, little publicized battle at Wanat in eastern Afghanistan (near the Pakistani border) on July 13, 2008 that resulted in nine dead and 27 wounded American troops is calling the weapon's reliability into question. Unfortunately, the M4 carbine's performance in key battles is merely a synecdoche to a much larger problem that brings to mind the earliest stories concerning the war in Iraq.

A recent study by Douglas R. Cubbison, a military historian with the U.S. Army Combat Studies Institute at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, has listed some grave and troubling deficiencies at the command level just prior to the attack of the outpost that saw its young commander, Lt. Jonathan Brostrom, killed along with 8 of his men when they were overrun by 200 Taliban insurgents who came from a staging area in Pakistan and with the support of the local police department.

In fact, the deficiencies at the command structure were so glaring, that Congressional intervention is being called for. Gun rights advocate Sen. Tom Coburn (R-OK) has also been a vocal critic of the M4 of late. Here's what KITV in Hawaii said last year:
Brostrom's father, David, said he had been concerned about his son's safety even before the lieutenant died.

"They're fighting in a situation where they don't (have) enough troops on the ground and it's been like this for a long time," David Brostrom told KITV in July 2008.

Brostrom's father is a retired Army colonel who spent 30 years flying Army helicopters.

David Brostrom said during a home leave, his son told him he feared for the safety of his men without enough manpower to maintain security.

"That's when I started to worry about him," David Brostrom said.

At David Brostrom's urging, Rep. Neil Abercrombie and Virginia Sen. James Webb have called for an independent investigation by the Department of Defense's solicitor general.

An earlier Army investigation left commanders blameless.

A week and a half ago, Gen. David Petraeus, possibly trying to keep the matter as internal as possible and heading off a Pentagon IG probe, ordered his own investigation into the matter well over a year after the bloodbath.

Increasingly, US troops have been complaining that the M4 jams at the worst possible time. I can tell you from personal experience that a desert environment makes this especially likely if you don't strip, clean and oil your weapon very often. The troops and their superiors often check their ordinance and I have no reason to believe that paratroops wouldn't properly maintenance their weapons knowing fully good and well the effect that sand can have on any machine with moving parts.

"Today's weapon of choice" has time and again been discarded in the heat of battle for other weapons when the barrel overheated during firefights (Contrary to the TIME article, it's an impossibility for a gun to continue firing effectively when the barrel turns white hot. A breakdown would surely happen by the time the barrel turned red-hot.).

The choice of weapon is largely, if not totally, predicated on the terrain. Another determinative factor is the type of battle you'll be fighting, the enemy's range, their ordinance, etc. If you're expecting a full frontal assault by an enemy in vastly superior numbers, you may not want to go with a weapon with a 30 round clip. Even with six round bursts, you'll still find yourself reloading every minute or so. And in the middle of a 7 1/2 hour-long firefight, you will experience breakdowns. Where were the .50 calibers and other large bore full auto ordinance? Where were their own long-range weapons that could counter the Taliban's RPG's? Did they not have actual artillery? An adequate intelligence report gleaned by an unmanned surveillance drone could've answered all these questions (An Afghani tribal leader even asked about the drones in meetings with the US military).

This dovetails into the issue of the lack of heavy machinery. The 45 US and 20 Afghani troops of the Vehicle Patrol Base could only carry what they could carry and the issue of dysfunctional kinetics is what led to their deaths and ceding control of that area to the Taliban (the US Army bristled at the thought we retreated from an area of tactical importance, stating that Wanat was not considered important enough for long-range defense, which begs the question of why we sent a badly-equipped and badly-advised VPB there to begin with.). The bottom line is their ordinance was woefully not up to the task and they lacked the fortifications aside from what the natural terrain offered for an adequate defense.

Cubbison's report returned some other disturbing findings that's becoming tragically familiar:
According to Cubbison, a few days before the battle, on July 4, a US Army helicopter mistakenly attacked and killed 17 local Afghan civilians, including all of the Afghan doctors and nurses at a local clinic, infuriating local Afghans throughout the area. In response, platoon commander Brostrom and company commander Matthew Myer notified senior commanders that they were worried that a retaliatory attack was imminent and that extra surveillence was necessary. Rather than bolstering security around Wanat, however, US Army leaders at Bagram air base ordered the withdrawal of all intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance assets from the area.

And those are just some of the epic fails of this COIN (counterinsurgency) operation. It brings back memories of the misguided bombs that fell on Fallujah during Operation Desert Storm, the Iraqis' revenge on us in 2004, the two US retaliations and so forth.

US Army commanders were also slow-footed in both bringing to up speed and getting consent from the surrounding tribal elders whose support would've been crucial. In fact, it took them ten months, nearly a year, to bring these tribal leaders into the loop. These same commanders had also gotten word prior to the attack in Wanat that 200-300 insurgents were massing around the outpost and that there was a likelihood of a full frontal assault on our troops. They were attacked days later on two fronts of 100 Taliban militants each who were armed with RPGs (rocket-propelled grenade launchers).

And these same Army commanders, at the worst possible time, never personally scouted the outpost for its tactical suitability, pulled and diverted all unmanned drone recon, much-needed heavy machinery, no effective air support (although they did drop 500 pound bombs) and to fight a nearly hopeless battle with problematic weapons in which they were outmanned three and a half to one (45 US troops and 20 locals vs 200). Seven and a half hours after the assault started, nine US troops were dead with no reason for the tactical failure and the inexplicable decisions by their commanders.

Such oversight would be reprehensible if America was fighting its first COIN campaign. But we've been in Afghanistan for over eight years, which as George Will recently said is over twice the length of time of our combined involvement in both world wars. Such command failures after all these years are absolutely unforgivable.

(Cubbison's report has yet to find its way onto the internet and has been released only to the AP and very few other news outlets. If anyone can find a link to a copy of the report, please pass it along so I can post it.)


At October 11, 2009 at 12:52 PM, Blogger Stan B. said...

In the long run, don't matter much what weapons ya got if the people you're fighting for and against have got it in for ya...

At October 11, 2009 at 2:04 PM, Anonymous Lisa G. said...

Fuck artillery - where are the damned tanks and aircraft? Why are 8 guys trying to fend off 200-300 Taliban without air or ground cover?

My neighbor is an Iraq war vet - Marines - I know for a fact, they clean those weapons EVERYDAY without fail. There is no reason for this M4 piece of shit to be in the field. And fuck the M16's too - where are the machine guns (M60's) with 500 rounds at a crack? $600B Defense budget and these guys can't defend themselves? It's just sick how we leave these guys out there....with nothing but their helmets and their guts. Makes me sick.

At October 11, 2009 at 2:04 PM, Anonymous Lisa G. said...

Sorry for the language, but this REALLY pisses me off and makes me cry.

At October 11, 2009 at 8:14 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Lisa it deserves heavier language
than that! Where is the heavy shit?

At October 11, 2009 at 11:18 PM, Blogger jurassicpork said...

Lisa, it wasn't eight guys fighting off 200 Taliban militants. It was more like 65. They were vastly outnumbered, sure, but there more than that killed.

At October 12, 2009 at 1:36 AM, Anonymous Lisa G. said...

Doesn't matter if there were 8 or 60 or 800! WE HAVE SHIT TO DEAL WITH THIS!!

I'm sorry, but living across the street, from a Marine, who served two tours, is trying to have a normal, relationship, has PTSD, is seeing a psychologist for help, is 30 MF years old, has seen more ugly shit than I will ever see in my ENTIRE life, THIS PISSES ME OFF TO NO END.


Sorry, for the language, caps, etc. but this is complete and utter BULLSHIT.

PS. That woman who got both her legs blown off flying a copter in Iraq is now Chairwoman of our VA here in IL. She's getting a call, on behalf of my neighbor and all my IL vets, on my behalf tomorrow.

At October 12, 2009 at 1:44 AM, Anonymous Lisa G. said...

And since the VA hospital is just a few clicks down the road, I'll be volunteering in my spare time. I encourage everyone to do the same.

Everyone needs someone to cry with and if I have to be that person, I'm willing to do it.

At October 12, 2009 at 2:10 AM, Blogger jurassicpork said...

Tammy Duckworth? I was hoping she would get into Congress. She almost did it, too. She spoke at the '06 Democratic convention, didn't she?

At October 12, 2009 at 11:24 AM, Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

The M4 is not retrofitted for the grenade launcher but rather is designed to fit the standard issue device. There is no fitting required, you simply bolt it up.
As for the grenade launchers on the m14/7.62 I'd surely like to see a pic of that item as I know of no way to affix a grenade launcher to this rifle. Hell i've never even seen a M1 type grenade launcher fitted to the m14.
I'm not a fan of the black rifles and have written a few articles that go back a few years, to sum up , this malfunction problem is not new. The stats indicate that about 9 % of troops have had a malfunction in combat in Iraq.Jessica Lynch is a fine example of this fact.
I've written extensively on Wanat and must say that fire discipline was poor and soldiers must use their weapons within their limitations. Firing bursts only serves to overheat the individual rifle.In addition their MG's were overheated by extensive full auto fire.There's a thing called fire discipline even in a fight.It's easy to say but that's something paratroopers should do.
I've written about the absence of organic mortar defensive fires from these fights.This would take pressure off the individual riflemen.
Incidentally a defensive position that is beaten by enemy plunging fire is NOT a defensive position but rather a death trap.The Wanat fight violated US infy doctrine,plain and simple.
Why was the defense not weighted with extra direct fire auto weapons?
There is plenty of literature on the cleaning and lube requirements of the M4.The problem boils down to -too much lube only attracts dirt and will stop the weapon and too little will overheat it and stop it.Both are bad. There are better systems available, it's instructive that SOF assets usually choose other available systems.
Lisa G,
You sound like a fine person but emotion will not trump cold attacks on the stupidity of the wars.
It's wonderful to hear of someone volunteering at the DVA hospitals.
jim hruska at

At October 12, 2009 at 1:13 PM, Blogger jurassicpork said...

On the M14, they were side-mounted, like the more modern XM8 (which is a proposed replacement for the M4 carbine, which is actually more ideally-suited for those poor guys at Wanat, since it's made for vehicle troops).

As for the M14, back in the early-mid 60's, grenade launchers such as the M76 could be retrofitted to the M14 since their manufacture was later than the older M14's. They just never became standard like the 40 mm M79 and, later, the M203 (I can't find a picture anywhere that shows an M14 with an M76 mounted on it. Sorry. But the union of the two has been documented.). Nowadays, they all come in a piece, such as the 7.62 mm SCARs.

At October 12, 2009 at 4:52 PM, Blogger rangeragainstwar said...

The m76 was a replacement or fitted to the flash hider. It was a improvement on the M1 launcher that req'd a cartridge to launch the grenade.
I served in a line infy div in 1969 and Never saw one used on a rifle nor did we even familiarize with them. This was when the m14 was standard issue.
But this is old news, what's important is that troops today are dying b/c of weapons malfunctions. We both agree on this.

At October 14, 2009 at 11:12 AM, Anonymous Lisa G. said...

Yes, JP, you are right. Tammy Duckworth. And she did almost get into Congress, but she ran in a really Republican district in suburban Chicago. She came really close though - closer than any other any other Dem has gotten in years.

I couldn't remember her name - I was too pissed off.

At October 14, 2009 at 11:15 AM, Anonymous Lisa G. said...

I know emotion won't solve this which is why I'm not in politics - I'd get pissed off, start swearing and it would be all over. The husband is much calmer; he's going in. He's a recovering Republican, but he's shaping up nicely. I'm doing some fine work over here!


Post a Comment

<< Home

KindleindaWind, my writing blog.

All Time Classics

  • Our Worse Half: The 25 Most Embarrassing States.
  • The Missing Security Tapes From the World Trade Center.
  • It's a Blunderful Life.
  • The Civil War II
  • Sweet Jesus, I Hate America
  • Top Ten Conservative Books
  • I Am Mr. Ed
  • Glenn Beck: Racist, Hate Monger, Comedian
  • The Ten Worst Music Videos of all Time
  • Assclowns of the Week

  • Links to the first 33 Assclowns of the Week.
  • Links to Assclowns of the Week 38-63.
  • #106: The Turkey Has Landed edition
  • #105: Blame it on Paris or Putin edition
  • #104: Make Racism Great Again Also Labor Day edition
  • #103: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Toilet edition
  • #102: Orange is the New Fat edition
  • #101: Electoral College Dropouts edition
  • #100: Centennial of Silliness edition
  • #99: Dr. Strangehate edition
  • #98: Get Bentghazi edition
  • #97: SNAPping Your Fingers at the Poor edition
  • #96: Treat or Treat, Kiss My Ass edition
  • #95: Monumental Stupidity double-sized edition
  • #94: House of 'Tards edition
  • #93: You Da Bomb! edition.
  • #92: Akin to a Fool edition.
  • #91: Aurora Moronealis edition.
  • #90: Keep Your Gubmint Hands Off My High Pre'mums and Deductibles! edition.
  • #89: Occupy the Catbird Seat/Thanksgiving edition.
  • #88: Heil Hitler edition.
  • #87: Let Sleeping Elephants Lie edition.
  • #86: the Maniacs edition.
  • #85: The Top 50 Assclowns of 2010 edition.
  • #(19)84: Midterm Madness edition.
  • #83: Spill, Baby, Spill! edition.
  • #82: Leave Corporations Alone, They’re People! edition.
  • #81: Hatin' on Haiti edition.
  • #80: Don't Get Your Panties in a Twist edition.
  • #79: Top 50 Assclowns of 2009 edition.
  • #78: Nattering Nabobs of Negativism edition.
  • #77: ...And Justice For Once edition.
  • #76: Reading Tea Leaves/Labor Day edition.
  • #75: Diamond Jubilee/Inaugural Edition
  • #74: Dropping the Crystal Ball Edition
  • #73: The Twelve Assclowns of Christmas Edition
  • #72: Trick or Treat Election Day Edition
  • #71: Grand Theft Autocrats Edition
  • #70: Soulless Corporations and the Politicians Who Love Them Edition
  • Empire Of The Senseless.
  • Conservative Values for an Unsaved World.
  • Esquire's Charles Pierce.
  • Brilliant @ Breakfast.
  • The Burning Platform.
  • The Rant.
  • Mock, Paper, Scissors.
  • James Petras.
  • Towle Road.
  • Avedon's Sideshow (the new site).
  • At Largely, Larisa Alexandrovna's place.
  • The Daily Howler.
  • The DCist.
  • Greg Palast.
  • Jon Swift. RIP, Al.
  • God is For Suckers.
  • The Rude Pundit.
  • Driftglass.
  • Newshounds.
  • William Grigg, a great find.
  • Brad Blog.
  • Down With Tyranny!, Howie Klein's blog.
  • Wayne's World. Party time! Excellent!
  • Busted Knuckles, aka Ornery Bastard.
  • Mills River Progressive.
  • Right Wing Watch.
  • Earthbond Misfit.
  • Anosognosia.
  • Echidne of the Snakes.
  • They Gave Us a Republic.
  • The Gawker.
  • Outtake Online, Emmy-winner Charlotte Robinson's site.
  • Skippy, the Bush Kangaroo
  • No More Mr. Nice Blog.
  • Head On Radio Network, Bob Kincaid.
  • Spocko's Brain.
  • Pandagon.
  • Slackivist.
  • WTF Is It Now?
  • No Blood For Hubris.
  • Lydia Cornell, a very smart and accomplished lady.
  • Roger Ailes (the good one.)
  • BlondeSense.
  • The Smirking Chimp.
  • Hammer of the Blogs.
  • Vast Left Wing Conspiracy.
  • Argville.
  • Existentialist Cowboy.
  • The Progressive.
  • The Nation.
  • Mother Jones.
  • Vanity Fair.
  • Citizens For Legitimate Government.
  • News Finder.
  • Indy Media Center.
  • Lexis News.
  • Military Religious Freedom.
  • McClatchy Newspapers.
  • The New Yorker.
  • Bloggingheads TV, political vlogging.
  • Find, the next-best thing to Nexis.
  • Altweeklies, for the news you won't get just anywhere.
  • The Smirking Chimp
  • Don Emmerich's Peace Blog
  • Wikileaks.
  • The Peoples' Voice.
  • CIA World Fact Book.
  • IP address locator.
  • Tom Tomorrow's hilarious strip.
  • Babelfish, an instant, online translator. I love to translate Ann Coulter's site into German.
  • Newsmeat: Find out who's donating to whom.
  • Wikipedia.
  • Uncyclopedia.
  • Icasualties
  • Free Press
  • YouTube
  • The Bone Bridge.
  • Powered by Blogger